A Faithful Proposal - Review

A Faithful Proposal (Memorable Proposals, # 2)

By: Jennie Goutet

Publication: July 1, 2021 by Cedar Fort, Inc.

305 pages

Genre: Adult, Historical Fiction, Regency

Source: YouTube Audiobooks

( Goodreads | Amazon )

*Note: The above link to Amazon is an affiliate links. Affiliate links support giveaways for Somewhere Only We Know readers.

Goodreads description--She was born to lead London Society. He could not leave it fast enough.

With a few well-placed words in the right ear, Anna Tunstall can direct anyone to do her bidding, exactly the skill needed for one destined to be the wife of a man in politics. A summer visit to a friend’s country estate is the perfect distraction before the London Season begins and Anna can achieve her ambition of a perfect match.

Harry Aston has spurned the noble aspirations of his family to enter holy orders where he might make a difference in people’s lives. His mother’s untiring attempts to find him a wife worthy—and wealthy—enough to suit him only serve to set up his back. He has never been in love, and she should not think that suitable wives dropped down from heaven, especially not in the village of Avebury.

When Harry finds Anna unconscious on the road, and she awakens in his arms, his world shifts at her gaze. But before he can think that heaven has come through at last, he must convince Anna that her prolonged stay in Avebury is not fate’s way of toying with her, but rather opening her eyes to a new direction for her ambitions—and her heart.

Anna is very different from me. Sometimes this makes reading a character more fun, and other times it makes them hard to relate to. Anna comes off as shallow. She likes gossip and fashion. And she bonded with...oh shoot...what was her name?...her friend over these things before her friend married and moved from London. Anna is now on her way to visit her friend before her confinement while her husband is away at war. Anna is headstrong and often disregards logic and sense for her own whims. She's one of those people that thinks "Oh, that could never happen to me." But it seems "that" often does happen to her.

After dismissing the idea of traveling with any sort of male escort and only hiring a temporary maid, her coach is robbed by highwaymen. Anna is found by Harry, the local vicar, and deposited with her friend to recover. Harry is almost immediately taken with Anna's beauty. But he needs to know there is more to Anna than her looks.

Harry is of noble birth, but all things London and high society rub him completely wrong. Most especially, his family. He does battle with wondering whether Anna is as surface level as she gives off because as a vicar, he needs his bride to be deeper than that and concerned with more than simply herself. Anna does rise to the occasion, but I was a little disappointed that he didn't probe deeper into her faith. As a vicar, I would imagine it isn't good enough to have a kind wife. Wouldn't you need a believing wife as well? And given the main role that Harry has, I would have expected to see some deeper religious themes used throughout the book. I wasn't put off by it, but it was something I noted.

A Faithful Propopsal has a few mysteries wrapped up in the overall storyline. Who are the highwaymen who robbed Anna at the beginning of the book? Why were her possessions returned to her? Anna's friend's husband is missing. Will he return or will she finally receive news that he is dead? Or will he remain missing? This was perhaps one of my favorite parts of the overall story, and I can't spoil anything surrounding it.

A Faitfhul Proposal wasn't a perfect book for me. I had a few issues with Anna as a character, to begin with. I wanted to see a little more depth to Anna where Harry was concerned. Sure I didn't expect her to change just for his sake, but are they truly the best fit for each other? I did enjoy the side stories because they didn't take over the main plot, but I felt like they truly did add to the story instead of take away which can sometimes happen in romantic mysteries. I give A Faithful Proposal 3 Stars. Have you read (or listened to) A Faithful Proposal? What did you think? Let me know!